Episodes / Owner Mindset / No. 673
The Estate Planning Mistake That Tears Families Apart (Jimmy Buffett's $275M Lesson)
Jimmy Buffett left a 275 million dollar trust, and now his widow and his longtime business manager are suing each other in two states while the legal bills run into the millions.
Listen instead and the audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
In this episode
The write up
Ryan Deiss and I spent this episode on one question, and it is a question that most advisors never put to their client. Is the estate plan that saves the most tax worth what it can do to your family? The Jimmy Buffett estate is what got me thinking about it. There was a $275 million trust, and his widow, who he had been married to for 46 years, and his business manager and trustee are in two separate lawsuits, one in Florida and one in California, spending millions of dollars on both sides.
Where we landed is easy to say and easy to forget. Unless your estate is well past $30 million, you probably don't need the complex structures at all. Even if it is, I would not have a plan that gave the people I loved the right to sue each other. We came at it from different places philosophically, but ended up in almost exactly the same place. None of this is legal advice, obviously. The law will change. This is just what we do.
What the Buffett fight is really about
What I saw on social media was that the wife and the kids were fighting. When I looked into it a little bit more, it turns out the bigger fight was between the widow and the trustee. Her complaint, as I understand it, was that six million plus went to legal fees. She's receiving two million a year from a $275 million estate. I don't know who's right. I don't know if that's a deal on the fees or not on a trust that big. But the point is that they created this structure that set up a fight.
The other thing that I mentioned was James Brown. He left his estate to a scholarship fund for underprivileged kids, and it stayed tied up for years. I think it was about 15 years in, and I think that a judge was saying the only kids that have gotten an education out of this are the children of the lawyers.
I have seen it up close too. We had a neighbor that we did a couple of deals with. He was a widower, and he and his wife had built up a company and sold it and done all the planning that you would do. When she died, some of the assets were sitting in her irrevocable trust with the children as beneficiaries. One daughter and her husband decided that they didn't like how he was managing the investments. He's an entrepreneur and he's got a lot of things going on that they don't understand. Maybe they were good decisions, maybe they weren't. But what matters is that somebody other than him had standing to object to how he was running his own money.
I practiced estate law for about 12 years, so I knew these things. I knew how to set them up. I believed in them. But then I watched theory go to practice. I saw people who created charitable trusts and took out of those trusts the money they needed to live on and had the charity come after them. I know that's a low percentage of cases. As an attorney, you see the ones that go wrong so much more than you see the ones that are successful. But the damage to a family cannot be recovered, and I don't think any chance of that is worth saving the 40% estate tax.
Who needs complex trusts
Right now a couple can leave $30 million with no estate tax, and that number is indexed for inflation. So Ryan's first question to anybody who is pitching a complicated structure is, do you have more than $30 million to worry about? He said that if you look at business owners who have a couple million in assets and then maybe get another 10 or 15 million from the sale of their business, they're being sold on this planning mechanism that was supposedly the thing that the Rockefellers used. And he's watched people spend six figures to have trusts set up for estates of five million dollars.
Ryan was harder on the advisors than me. I do not think that they're unscrupulous. I don't think that most professionals are. I think they're doing what they were taught, and I think the client walked in and said, we want to minimize taxes. What is missing, I think, is just that human side: somebody who has gone through a few of these saying, this is what could happen. Do you realize that if we were to do this, this could happen? And are you conscious and aware that you're choosing the tax planning over the potential family disruption?
So if your estate was only $7 million, it has to 4X before the question even comes up. Then revisit at that time. What Ryan said is, let's create the problem before we solve it.
What we each plan to leave our kids
That's where our philosophies are different. My philosophy is I want to help my kids get houses and I want to help them get an education. Once I've done that, my obligation's done. Anything that they inherit is a bonus. I would much rather spend it on experiences while we're all alive and healthy and have the ability to do things together. And I'm not going to try to control them from the grave. The one thing that I do believe in is installments. I've seen children inherit money that they weren't used to dealing with and blow it. So if you can have a third at death, a third five years later, and a third 10 years later, then you're giving them two more chances to learn.
Ryan starts from his faith. His faith is that nothing he has is his. His job is to be a good steward of it and then pass it on to good stewards. He told us he doesn't think the government's the best steward, but he doesn't think it's good stewardship to leave your kids a pile of tension just to not pay taxes either. So it's kind of binary for him. If you're a good steward, you get the full amount with no strings attached. If you would be destructive with it, you get nothing and hopefully the siblings will help. He told us that he's told his four kids to assume they get nothing. They have college paid for, no student debt, a car at graduation, and help with a down payment. And then, as he said, his job as a parent is to raise adults, not children.
What should happen to the business
The pushback from advisors is that the business is going to have to be fire sold to pay the tax. Ryan said he doesn't have any expectation his kids are going to inherit a business. He wants to sell the closely held assets before he dies. If one of them wants to continue to operate the company, that person should buy it and the others should be able to receive the value of their share. The other thing Ryan argued is that a child who has worked in the business for 15 years and grown it should be able to hold an additional stake of their own, just like any executive would.
I don't feel like I need to treat my kids equally on everything. One of them might love the wine, one of them might love a particular car. That's going to come off the top. On the tax itself, there is generally a rule that allows you to pay the estate tax on a business over 14 years, so that there isn't a fire sale. Then you can use an irrevocable life insurance trust to fund one child buying the others out. Nobody fights over a term policy. You get it and it has no value until you die. And what Ryan added at the end there, which I completely agree with, is to tell your family the formula while you're alive so that there's no surprise.
The simple moves that protect a family
These are the moves that I would take to your attorney.
- If you name a trustee, give your beneficiaries the right to remove and replace that person without going to court to prove mismanagement. Otherwise you have locked your family in a cage and handed someone else the key. Ryan said he had not thought of that one and was going to make some calls.
- When the first spouse dies, make sure the estate tax return, the 706, gets filed and the box is checked to keep the unused exemption. As I understand the current rule, you have about nine months. Miss it and you can lose a $15 million exclusion, which is six million dollars in tax.
- Give things away while you are alive, so you get to watch people enjoy them.
- Fund whatever liquidity your death will require through a life insurance trust.
None of those gives anyone a claim against anyone else, and that is the test I would apply to the whole plan. In my words from the episode, "You don't want to create standing between people you love." Ryan's closing advice was to ask every advisor what the risk is that the people you love end up in conflict after you are gone, and how to avoid it even if it costs more in tax. The standard advice is built around the spreadsheet, and that question is how you get the human side considered before you sign.
Written from the recording of this episode of Business Lunch.
Show notes
In This Episode Of Business Lunch: Jimmy Buffett left a 275 million dollar trust, and now his widow and his longtime business manager are suing each other in two states while the legal bills run into the millions. Roland Frasier, who practiced estate law for about 12 years, and Ryan Deiss use that fight to make a case most advisors never make: the estate plan that saves the most tax is often the one that tears the family apart. They cover who actually needs complex trusts (almost nobody under 30 million dollars), what they each plan to leave their own kids, what should happen to the business, and the few simple moves that protect a family without giving anyone you love the right to sue anyone else you love. This is a conversation about what they do themselves, not legal advice.
Follow Roland Frasier:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rolandfrasier/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rolandfrasier/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rolandfrasier
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RolandFrasierPage/
Everything else: https://msha.ke/rolandfrasier/
Follow Ryan Deiss:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ryandeiss/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandeiss/
Visit: https://www.scalable.co
Free tools that go with this one
- 1Scale & Exit AssessmentAbout five minutes. A score out of 100, what your business is worth today and after the fixes, and the 11 value killers capping the number, in a 15 page report.score.scalable.co (opens in a new tab)
- 2Exit Ready ScoreA three minute read on how a buyer would size up your business and where you are most exposed.getexitreadyscore.com (opens in a new tab)



