Episodes / Exit Readiness / No. 650
Mastering Business Valuation: The Power of Quality of Earnings
We explore the critical factors that influence business valuation, focusing on Quality of Earnings (Q of E), recurring revenue, customer and channel diversity, and deal structures.
In this episode
The write up
Ryan Deiss came back and said that when I was talking about that Q of E thing a few days earlier, when I was throwing it out there, he was like, oh, okay, I get it. And then he realized he didn't actually know what it is or why it exists, and a number of his clients don't know either. So the question on the table became pretty plain. What is a quality of earnings report? Why do we care about it? And how can we improve ours?
We landed at this: good profitability and good growth get you in the door, but they don't really get you a great valuation or a great deal structure. It's Q of E that is going to determine where you fall on the multiple spectrum and how much of the headline price is going to show up as cash. I think that was the thing we agreed on almost entirely. He was pushing for specifics, and I gave them to him where I had them.
What a quality of earnings report measures
A Q of E report really asks just one question. How risky is the revenue that we've got coming in, given that somebody else is going to take over this company and needs to continue to get all that revenue and be able to grow it the same way it has been growing in the past?
These reports are expensive to get done. The companies that do them charge somewhere between a hundred K and 300 K. So if you were selling a million dollar business, you wouldn't want to do this. But if you're at a higher level, even if you're at 10 million or so, the buyers are really concerned about risk. Credit has tightened and gotten more expensive, and companies have not realized the value that they thought they would in acquisitions. So Q of E has become one of the things that comes up quite a bit. If you can get a good report done, then you'll be able to reduce the buyer's risk, and that means you're going to be able to command a higher price.
The first thing that they look at is recurring revenue. Why does recurring revenue matter? Well, if you've got annual or monthly contracts, then that's not revenue that has to be earned every month, so they're going to look at that. They're also going to say, how sure are you that those people are going to continue to pay? That's the churn question. That's the retention question. That's the net retained revenue question. Ryan guessed that customer quality matters as well, that enterprise revenue is more durable than small business and startup revenue. My answer was that it's more the credit worthiness of the clients as opposed to the mix. Are they paying on time? What does the accounts receivable cycle look like? What's the write off rate? Ryan tied that to the first time he tried to rent office space. The landlord wouldn't rent to him because a brand new business with no credit would bring down the value of the property when they sold it.
Buyers also look at customer concentration, and they look at the prospects for the industries that your clients are in. If there's a major disruption in the industry and your client is going to be affected by that, like a lot of businesses right now are because of AI, then you might take a ding for that as well. Then we go to channel diversity and founder dependency. Channel diversity asks, are all your sales coming from one place? If all your sales are coming from Amazon, that's a big risk. Founder dependency says that if the founder is generating the revenue or the founder has to perform the fulfillment, then there's a challenge there. That's why speaking and guru type businesses sell for really low multiples.
How a weak report eats the headline price
The part that I spent the most time on is deal structure. When the report comes back weak, we move from cash, where the risk sits with the buyer, to the deferred components, which are going to be seller financing, contingent value rights or an earn out. And I think it's in the 80% plus range of earn outs that don't perform the way the seller thought they would.
The other thing is the math that we walked through. The roll in, the share of your proceeds that the buyer wants reinvested in the new entity, has gone from a typical 20% up to about 35%. Now you're down to 65%. Earn outs are ranging between 10 and 40%, so let's say 25%. Maybe there's 20% seller financing. You're really only going to get about 20% of that headline price upfront. And that's before you even get to the holdback, which might be another 10 or 15% sitting in escrow for three or four years. So you might not even get enough to replace the income the business was paying you. I think it's important, and I called it this fatal subtraction.
Ryan's point was that most people think about a sale as being EBITDA times a multiple. That's way too simple, because what you're really getting is a range. I told him I'm seeing most offers for companies that have good operating systems and good Q of E start in the six to eight, eight and a half range. And we very often push to double digits, so the 10, 12, even 15 range.
He was able to put those two things together. He said, well, if I can get a stronger Q of E, then that's going to get me a higher multiple, and I'll get more of it in cash. I put the six at you getting 35 to 40% of the headline price. He said that becomes maybe a 10 where you're taking home 60 or 70%. On a small deal, that could be the difference between taking home half a million bucks and taking home four.
What to fix first
The next thing Ryan asked me was what someone who is an owner doing a few million a year should do right away. If I had to pick one thing, it would be net retained revenue. What's the target for net retained revenue? If you didn't have to sell another customer, then a year from now you'd be better off. So over 100% is wonderful. Ryan explained how that works. It's basically if you can keep hopefully 90% plus of your customers, and the ones that stay spend more year over year because they go up through higher tiers of service. I added upsells and getting a larger share of wallet from people who are currently splitting their spend across multiple vendors.
Ryan argued that the inverse is hitting SaaS companies right now. What's happening is their customers' headcount is going down because of AI, so seat based revenue retention is going down. But it's not because they don't want the software anymore. It's just that there are fewer people. So maybe you should think about changing your pricing model if you're on a seat license.
I also mentioned product range. When Steve Jobs came back to Apple, he said, we've got all these products, 13 or 15 or something, and he cut that to four. I think that's an important thing to look at too. What are the things that are the most profitable? Can you trim off some of the 80% of effort that's only getting you 20% of the profits and really focus on those? And last but not least, can you add services? Because services tend to be recurring.
Ryan asked for numbers. Every deal is different, but more than 10% dependence on any one customer starts to have an impact. We have one company right now where three or four customers are about 40% of income, and that's scary. Channels are harder to put one number on: a hundred affiliates is less of a challenge than Amazon being 70% of your business. On recurring revenue, I don't have enough data to be precise, but 50% or more is good and buyers would like to see 70 or 80. And 4% churn a month means roughly half your customers leave every year, so you need better than 50% growth just to grow.
It's better to start a year or two before you need the report. Ryan added the reason: even if you fix these things, buyers are not going to believe you until the data comes back.
The order buyers look at things
I said, you know what the biggest reason is that I see acquisitions not realize the value? The acquirer just doesn't understand how much that scrappy, hustling founder was actually driving the company. Ryan said, absolutely. And then he said you don't want to be known as the scrappy entrepreneur from the outside anymore. You want it to look like someone from McKinsey could walk in and run it.
Then Ryan asked me, is there a secret? I said EBITDA is number one. That's table stakes. Then CAGR, because you want to show them that you are a growing company and not a declining company. Then they dive into Q of E, and the first thing there is how much recurring revenue. Ryan said it was third, but not a distant third. And I said yes, because that's really where the multiple gets decided, along with the cash versus deferred split.
Platform or tuck in
I think the last point may be the most important. If you've got a strong Q of E, you're going to be much more likely to be looked at as a platform acquisition, which is going to have a higher multiple than a tuck in. Ryan's line was that you want to be a roller and not a rolly. Either way, you're probably going to be required to roll in anyway, so being the platform gives you more room to negotiate on the front end and then more upside when you get your second bite at the apple, when that business sells again.
Ryan's addition was optionality. If the people who are buying are able to tell that they don't need you, you can walk away, or if you've proven that you build great systems, they might want you to stay. Then he said, look, if you never sell, you'll still have a business that is stronger and more durable. I agreed with all of that. A higher Q of E, I think, is going to make your life easier.
Written from the recording of this episode of Business Lunch.
Show notes
In This Episode of Business Lunch: We explore the critical factors that influence business valuation, focusing on Quality of Earnings (Q of E), recurring revenue, customer and channel diversity, and deal structures. They share actionable insights for entrepreneurs aiming to maximize their business value and prepare for successful exits.
Connect with me on social:
- TikTok: Check out my TikTok Here
- Instagram: Check out my Instagram Here
- Facebook: Check out my Facebook Here
- LinkedIn: Check out my LinkedIn Here
- Subscribe to my YouTube 👉 Here
Resources:
Free tools that go with this one
- 1Scale & Exit AssessmentAbout five minutes. A score out of 100, what your business is worth today and after the fixes, and the 11 value killers capping the number, in a 15 page report.score.scalable.co (opens in a new tab)
- 2Exit Ready ScoreA three minute read on how a buyer would size up your business and where you are most exposed.getexitreadyscore.com (opens in a new tab)

