Episodes / Owner Mindset / No. 649
The Morality of Mass Layoffs: What Business Leaders Need to Know
We explore the ethics and practicalities of layoffs, the importance of stewardship in business, and how to handle difficult decisions with empathy and professionalism.
In this episode
The write up
The question started with a headline that was circulating around. It said Oracle fires 30,000 employees with a cold email at 6 a.m. or something like that. Ryan Deiss took it and split it into two questions. Is a layoff like that moral in the first place, particularly when you're posting record profits? And is the way that they did it wrong? We ended up agreeing on both. Letting people go isn't a moral failure when it's good stewardship of the company. And at 30,000 people, I don't know that either of us could think of a better way to deliver the news than one message that reaches everybody at the same time.
Where that leaves a business owner is the part Ryan closed on. He said that if you've been thinking for a good long while that you need to let somebody go, you probably need to let them go, and that you shouldn't let people who have never run a business make you feel guilty about being a good steward of yours.
We have done this ourselves
I asked Ryan if he remembered how he felt when we had to let those 265 people go. I think it was in December, maybe 15 years ago or so. Ryan said, awful. He said some of the worst days of his life were the days that preceded a layoff. Then he added that it was probably worse for the people who lost the jobs.
But the context matters. In our situation, we were funding the company from our personal bank accounts. There was not going to be a company or jobs for more than another month or so. So I think the better thing was to let them know what was going on and then have a process for them finding work again. It would have been irresponsible to run the company until we were all bankrupt and leave them without jobs 30 to 60 days later. But I wish that it hadn't been necessary. Ryan and I both lost a lot because that company wasn't successful. I don't feel bad about it morally. It sucks and that is what happens.
Stewardship is the moral question
The more interesting case is the wildly profitable company. Ryan pointed out that everything he saw framed it as Oracle laying off 30,000 people after record quarterly profits. I added that Ellison is consistently ranked among the richest people in the world. I think he's number two right now.
I still don't come out in a different place. A big public company has taken public money. People's pensions are invested in it. If you're unnecessarily employing 30,000 people, that's a lot of money. It's not fair to the people who invested for you to be a poor steward of the company. I also think it's morally wrong to keep people in roles where they are no longer needed. They'll never get promoted. They'll be a burden. And people are going to look for reasons to let them go. So the kindest thing is to tell them and give them a transition period. To me, where I draw the moral line is support. If you're doing really well, it would be not cool to skip the relocation, re employment and re education help that a lot of these bigger companies have.
Ryan picked up the stewardship framing and took it further. His framing was that your first moral authority as an executive is to the owners of the company. And even if you own all of it, there are other people who are likely to be in your life who depend on you. Then he said the thing that he expected to be unpopular: the job of business is not to employ people. He called it a team sport with roster changes. I agree with him. It's not a family, no matter how many people say it is. As he read it, Oracle made the resource allocation decision towards data centers and AI capital investment and away from human capital. They could be right or wrong, but he didn't see any moral wrong in making that decision.
Loyalty that only runs one direction
Ryan pointed to the person from the coverage who drove up from Texas with the sign saying they spent 12 years building the data center. My response was, well, for which you were paid. He said yes, but he does feel genuinely bad for that person. Then he inverted it. What if they'd quit to go work for Google, and Oracle executives came out with picket signs outside their house saying, we paid you for 12 years, how dare you?
I called it an asymmetric loyalty expectation. Companies are supposed to be loyal to employees. But if you go back to the great resignation, when people were going to whoever paid the most, I didn't hear any big pushback about that from anyone, including business. It's a transactional relationship.
Ryan admitted that he was guilty of it early in his career, the self righteous version of it, how dare they leave and all that kind of stuff. He said that he has had to talk clients and friends off that ledge. One of his stories was about Susie, who started at his company in customer support, learned community management there, got poached by Facebook, and felt guilty. He asked her what they would pay her. He said, I would never be able to pay you that. So he told her she had to take it. Now, when he talks about it in the interview process, he says this is a mutually exploitative relationship. My only ask is notice and you leaving on good terms. And my promise to you is the same in return.
The one thing I said that is comical to me is how many business journalists are not business people. So many people who are doing business news don't have any business experience. I think it's comical. Ryan's concern was the smaller business owner who is watching that and then waiting to make decisions.
What the person on the other end can do with it
Ryan was hoping that at least a few of the 30,000 were saying, what could be great about this? My own experience is that I've had a lot of really bad things happen to me, and they have put me in a position to be significantly better off. The divorce was the gut punch of all gut punches. It took me a good year of not wanting to get out of bed to get through that. But it put me in a place that ultimately was significantly better. Once you've been there and seen yourself go through something like that, you're going to be less afraid the next time. Now I will grant you, if it's your first job and you've been there 12 years and you just bought a house, that is a tough spot.
Ryan's version is being rejected by the business school at the University of Texas because of a C in ancient Greek. He thought his professional life was broken. What happened instead is that he started his own business.
The method depends on the scale
I don't think there's any problem with a text or an email at that scale, because most of those are not really personal relationships in the first place. I also don't think anybody can have empathy and stay empathetic across 30,000 conversations. But if it was a company of 20 or 30 people and you had played golf with somebody for years, then that email would be pretty cold in that context.
Ryan gave us the working rule. If you're letting a couple of people go, have the conversations individually, face to face, and it should be the leader who made the decision having them, not somebody who was brought in from outside. Once it gets to be more than about 10, his advice was to deliver it collectively and all at once, in a room or remotely, depending on how the team normally communicates, so it doesn't trickle out and people have others around them. Personally, I would not want to be in that room. I'd rather get the email.
Written from the recording of this episode of Business Lunch.
Show notes
In This Episode of Business Lunch: We explore the ethics and practicalities of layoffs, the importance of stewardship in business, and how to handle difficult decisions with empathy and professionalism. Roland Frasier and Ryan Deiss share insights from their experiences, emphasizing the importance of long term thinking and human centered leadership.
Connect with me on social:
- TikTok: Check out my TikTok Here
- Instagram: Check out my Instagram Here
- Facebook: Check out my Facebook Here
- LinkedIn: Check out my LinkedIn Here
- Subscribe to my YouTube 👉 Here
Resources:
Free tools that go with this one
- 1RGR100 growth readiness scoreTen minutes on how fast the business can actually grow, and a one page 90 day sprint to move it. Exit Ready measures how sellable you are. This measures how fast you can grow.rgr100.lovable.app (opens in a new tab)
- 2Leverage ScorecardA three minute score on how much of your growth runs on other people's money, resources and time.getleveragescore.com (opens in a new tab)

