Episodes / Leverage First Growth / No. 667
When to Let the Dumpster Fire Burn (and Why AI Is Breaking Hiring)
Not every problem in your business is yours to fix.
Listen instead and the audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
In this episode
The write up
Ryan Deiss brought a really simple question to this episode. When do you let the dumpster fire burn? His argument was that there are problems caused by forces outside the business, and those are usually not yours to fix. Where we landed on that was, first you ask, did I cause it? If you did not, then you control what you can control, you do the easy, obvious things really well, and you put your energy on the fire that is creating the biggest bottleneck.
Then we moved to a fire that is raging right now for a lot of businesses, which is hiring. AI written resumes are making it very hard to screen candidates. Ryan walked through the fixes that he has seen work and made the case for a role that he thinks is going to be needed in a lot of growing companies sooner than they think, and that is the internal recruiter.
The show up rate that started it
Ryan had just gotten off a call with Jeremy, who is his head of sales. Show up rate had been rough for a couple of weeks. It had gone red on the Monday scorecard. Jeremy had some ideas for how they could deal with that, and Ryan walked us through it. The way they do their scorecard is red means we're behind and we don't know what to do about it. Yellow means we're behind and we have an idea. So Jeremy was following the process.
Then Ryan asked him, why do you think it's down? We recorded this July 15th, so the previous two weeks in the States would have been holiday and vacation time. A lot of people were traveling and rescheduling. Ryan was saying that if you're trying to fix that, you're trying to defy gravity. And he said if you didn't break it, then you probably can't fix it.
The first thing that came to mind for me was, what do the airlines do? If you know that show up rates are down, then you should just book twice as many calls if the volume is there and not worry about overbooking. Summer has historically been a down time of year for pretty much every business we've had. So you've got to book a whole lot more to get the same number of shows.
Ryan agreed, and he said that's his first move too. Control what you can control. That starts with lead flow, and he said June was a record breaking month for his company, still summer, because lead flow was high. So double booking was one of the places that Ryan and Jeremy landed on.
The next thing Ryan said was to make sure the things his team knows are easy and obvious are happening in the handoff between the first call and the second call. Ryan listed them:
- Clearly identify the problem you are solving, so the prospect knows why the next call matters.
- Hit that problem hard in the follow up email.
- Make a text introduction, not just an email one, between the first salesperson and the person taking the second call.
Ryan's point on that was, if things are going great, then nobody is really going to notice that those things are being skipped, because the good times cover for a lot of shortcomings. But if things are not going well, you at least do the easy and obvious stuff. You might not close the full gap, but you'll definitely do a whole lot better than if you're just pushing against gravity. And then you keep the gains when the season turns.
How to tell which fires can wait
I wanted to push on the other side of it. This one can burn because it has an end date, and it is a repeating challenge. It's mostly July and August, and I think August is usually the worst. I think people are getting their last vacations in, and then they're heading back to school with their kids. But my read was that the World Cup and the 250th anniversary of the United States pulled some of that usual August dip forward into July this year. Ryan said he bought that, and he's been locked in to the World Cup himself, even though he doesn't really care about soccer.
So the fire will be starved of fuel. But what about the ones that can't wait? Don't make the mistake of letting something burn that has no finite date or one that's going to burn the whole house.
Ryan's answer was that the scariest fire is the one that you know you created. So the very first question that Ryan asked Jeremy was, had they done anything differently? And they had. They had moved their best setter into an AE position, which affects sets. If you caused it, Ryan argued, then you can probably reverse it and get back to what you were doing before. This one was a combination. It was partly seasonal and partly something they did that they weren't going to undo, because they did it for a good reason.
Should you make changes in a slow season?
That raised a question that I asked Ryan both ways. If you know that's the terrible time in almost every business that we own, then that's probably the worst time to do experiments, because you're not going to know if the new AE is great or not when there's so much less volume for them to work with. My alternative argument would be that it's actually the best time to do that, because you're going to have the least amount of damage if it doesn't work out.
Ryan said he tends to test new things in good times when there's a surplus, and you fix things that are broken when they're broken. In this case, the person had earned the promotion on the career path that his sales department had, so not giving the promotion would have been wrong. But he did say that waiting until after the Fourth of July holiday would have been a fair thing to do, and he counted it as a lesson learned.
Then Ryan made a bigger point, which was that there is never only one dumpster fire in a business. Owners get frustrated because they think that scale means putting them all out. His view was, no, it's not that. You're scaling by strategically selecting which ones you want to put out. I asked him, is that just theory of constraints, where you find the one fire that is creating the biggest constraint, the biggest bottleneck, and then you work on that one first? He said, yeah, that's exactly it. Then he went on to describe Jeremy's relief when he heard that the number is the number, and that the effort could go somewhere it would close the gap faster.
AI written resumes and what gets through them
Ryan and I had both read the Forbes article, which he cited as Why Small Businesses Aren't Hiring. The numbers he pulled from it were that 84 percent of business owners are trying to hire, and 67 percent of hiring managers say that AI written resumes are sabotaging their screening. One job post received 400 resumes, all of which looked like they were written by the same robot. And his team had candidates who had gotten on the phone and didn't even know which company they were talking to.
The article gave three fixes, and Ryan added a fourth from his own process.
- An application question so situational that AI can't fake it.
- A small paid project.
- A job description that tells the truth about the hard parts.
- A confirmation email before the interview that restates the role, the pay and the downsides, and invites people to opt out.
On the first one, I think that motivational based interviewing, which to me is the best of the best way to interview people, would fit, because it's give me specific situations where you did something. It's possible for AI to hallucinate and make things up, but it would help. Ryan agreed, and he told the story of Matt Swan, who is his head of marketing, asking follow up questions about a project on a resume and finding out that the candidate didn't even know that it was there.
On paid work, it was, yeah, we'll pay you, and then you have to build a 90 day plan of what you would do. That's just the way we do it, even with executives like CFOs. Ryan said that Matt went even further than that and spent 90 minutes on Zoom working through a problem with each candidate to see how they thought, and it didn't matter if they used AI. Hopefully they did. That's the tacos and tequila test. Is this somebody you want to work with?
Ryan said his company has long put a section at the bottom of every job post that says, here's why you won't like working here. And on his fourth step, he said they sent out the email and about a third of people opted out. A number of people wrote back, more excited.
The internal recruiter, and channels for finding people
Ryan's thinking is that the internal recruiter is going to become a must have, and he thinks it's a role he would put in before anyone else in HR, probably at the point where you're making a hire or two a month. He thinks it's kind of like sales, and that it would fall more on the sales side than on the HR side. It would be someone who had a background in outbound, and that person would sit inside each department with the hiring manager. He said he was just thinking out loud here, and his company isn't doing this yet.
It makes sense to me. We have three recruiters in our tax prep business and multiple internal recruiters in our business services business. I think it really is essential. When you've got high turnover, you've got to have it. When you've got rapid growth, you've got to have it. The only thing is, what's the size at which it makes sense? And does a fractional internal recruiter work, or is that too hard?
The other thing I raised is that I think you're seeing the end of mass advertised job fulfillment. Just like we have channels of customer acquisition, we should also have channels of employee acquisition. Those channels might be paid referrals, which is kind of like a search arrangement. And for lower level roles especially, you need someone qualifying candidates before they even get to you. If not, then you're wasting your advertising dollars and you're wasting the time of the people who blocked out their day to interview somebody who was not worth interviewing in the first place.
Written from the recording of this episode of Business Lunch.
Show notes
Not every problem in your business is yours to fix. Roland Frasier and Ryan Deiss break down how to tell a seasonal slump from a fire you actually started, why the easy and obvious moves matter most when the numbers dip, and how AI written resumes are quietly breaking hiring for small businesses. Plus the internal recruiter role they think every growing company is about to need.
Roland Frasier:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rolandfrasier/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rolandfrasier/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rolandfrasier
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RolandFrasierPage/
More: https://msha.ke/rolandfrasier/
Ryan Deiss:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ryandeiss/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandeiss/
X: https://x.com/ryandeiss
Scalable: https://www.scalable.co
Free tools that go with this one
- 1RGR100 growth readiness scoreTen minutes on how fast the business can actually grow, and a one page 90 day sprint to move it. Exit Ready measures how sellable you are. This measures how fast you can grow.rgr100.lovable.app (opens in a new tab)
- 2Leverage ScorecardA three minute score on how much of your growth runs on other people's money, resources and time.getleveragescore.com (opens in a new tab)



