Episodes / Leverage First Growth / No. 621

The Collapse of the Funnel: How Trust Now Drives Every Purchase

In this episode of Business Lunch , Roland Frasier and Ryan Deiss explain how the classic four stage buying journey has collapsed into one moment, and why trust is the lid that keeps…

Roland Frasier and Ryan DeissOctober 9, 2025 · 42 min
Read

Listen instead and the audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

In this episode

The write up

What Ryan Deiss and I spent this episode talking about was what has happened to cause the traditional four stages of the buying process to collapse into one, and what a business does about it. Ryan said that it's not a funnel anymore. It's a popcorn popper. Your audience are the kernels of corn, and they're heating up at different times. The content that you and your competitors are putting out is the heat. And trust is the lid. That's what makes them pop in your pot instead of someone else's.

The episode before this one was identity trust. This one is competence trust and proximity trust, and it ends with a 14 day sprint that any business can run. Where did we land? We landed with Ryan saying that a founder on a budget should start by being their own trust agent, and that proximity trust is the most overlooked of the three and also the most scalable. I agreed with him on that.

Competence trust means the brand gets me

So what's the difference? Identity trust is seeing yourself in the person speaking for the company. Competence trust is a little bit different. Competence trust is that the brand gets me.

My example was Nike. The old tagline, Just Do It, was a command, the brand as drill sergeant. The new branding is Why Do It. On the show, I said I naturally don't like changes to ads. My first response was to question it, because Just Do It is what I got branded with. But I do think that it harmonizes with what's going on right now, and they've really tapped into the inner drive and the anxieties of Gen Z. It's asking why you should do it, so that they then just do it, which is kind of nice. Ryan said a couple of really interesting things, one of which was that a question invites a conversation and a conversation builds a relationship, whereas a command is obeyed or ignored. He said Nike already had our generation. Then he said he hadn't seen the campaign himself, which told him it's not being shown in the channels where he hangs out.

Here are the numbers that we brought. Personalization with these types of ads increased average order value by 15 percent, retention by 25 percent, and loyalty by 30 percent. Sephora's tutorials and demos resulted in a 13 percent increase in basket size when the buyers engaged first with the tutorial or demo.

The miss here is the Peloton holiday ad from 2019, in which a husband gifts his wife a Peloton. That was seen as sexist and tone deaf. The stock went down 15 percent over three days, a $1.5 billion loss. Ryan's point here is that you shouldn't assume this only happens to public companies just because your company isn't on a ticker. His diagnosis was that shame was a big part of where that buyer was, and the ad kind of rubbed their nose in it.

The framework I gave for competence is the why, what, where. You start with the why: why it matters, the myth you are busting or the pain you are solving. The what is what to do and how the product works. Usually that's a demo, a teardown, or a tutorial. The where is where they can get it, because the journey does not collapse if they can't buy. Then Ryan added what else you can do beyond myths. A brand can also have its unique points of view. It can say, this is where we stand, we believe this and this. That helps the people who agree to recognize themselves.

I walked through a tax advisory firm example. That was a 30 second video on why writing off your car lease doesn't work the way you think. It's filmed informally. It's the founder, or it's somebody relatable who is not the leader but somebody in the company, saying, here's the thing that doesn't work the way you think. Then you post it with a direct link to book a free consult. You track that, and you're expecting a 10 to 15 percent lift in average order value. I think what Ryan was saying was valuable too: the real value here is that this content names the prospect's pain. You're doing exactly what a doctor does. He says the ultimate signal of competence is the ability to describe your prospect's problem better than they can. The tactical thing that he gave was to take ChatGPT, give it a description of your ideal client, and ask for the top 10 problems in their own words. Then ask for 10 more, and do that twice. As he says, 30 is where the gold is.

Where Ryan and I split on friction

I brought up an article in MediaCat that called this desirable friction. I like the idea of friction, because frictionless is forgettable. Nike's question makes you stop and think. So does wondering, did I write my lease off wrong?

Ryan's position was that friction never leaves a sales process, so the question is where you are putting it. My position is that this is not friction in the process. This is friction you're creating in the mind of the customer that is causing them to take action. Ryan argued that that's what a good salesperson would do on the phone. Except that here they're walking through it themselves on their own time, and because they're coming to their own conclusion, they believe it. That made sense to me, and we moved on.

Proximity trust and the people closest to you

The idea of proximity trust is that the people who are closest to you will sell for you the best. My positive example was DSW, a campaign where they had augmented reality mirrors in store so that you could try on shoes, see how they looked with different styled outfits, and then buy in one step. It was 561 percent more reach from the posts that the employees did. Also, 70 percent of consumers tend to trust brands when employees are sharing. I also pointed to Starbucks barista TikToks, which had a hundred million plus views, and Apple retail, which Forrester ranked number one for customer experience and retention impact.

I asked Ryan how a service business does that without a tech play. Ryan said there are three ways to do it. You can accept the currency of the buyer and have regional domains, you can change the visuals on your ads by geography, and you can find micro influencers in your top cities. He told a story about a Nissan ad that he saw that had the skyline of Austin. Then he saw it again in Denver, and it was the skyline of Denver.

On why employees outperform, Ryan said that most people are employees, so an employee who speaks well of a brand is very powerful. My take was that you couldn't get your employees to do that if they didn't like you. Then Ryan said that the Chipotle employee ads look too professional. They would be better if they were shot on an iPhone. I agreed.

It really cuts both ways. I think of the United Airlines video, the viral video of a passenger being dragged off the plane. A few days after that, the stock went down 6 percent. They lost a billion dollars in market cap. When the frontline fails, the whole brand pays. The brand suffers.

Here's the framework. It's people, place, and proof. You've got trusted insiders or happy customers in the center, you've got a place, a real world setting, and you have the proof, tangible results that are happening in the moment. Ryan added proof of work for those of you who might not be able to show the end result. For my plumbing example, with the technicians doing the video before and after and having a monthly $100 gift card contest, he added a team prize on top of the individual prize so that more people would participate.

What to do with it

My frame is that celebrity can add fire to a campaign, but the risk is giant. It's expensive, and it's not a repeatable engine in the same way that these three trusts are. So I would say run a 14 day sprint.

  • Day one: pick a product or service and get your baseline customer acquisition cost and average order value.
  • Days two and three: recruit three happy customers and three insiders.
  • Days four to seven: record short videos using the frameworks.
  • Day eight: post them. Days nine through twelve: boost the top two.
  • Days 13 and 14: measure again and compare to baseline.

I asked him what somebody who has 500 bucks should be testing first. His answer was identity trust, with the founder as their own trust agent. Put out 30 to 50 posts and put 50 bucks behind each of the 10 that get traction. Ryan said proximity is the slowest to roll out. Then he said that it's easier to ask your team if you've gone first. And to the founders who were saying, I don't want to, he said, I don't either. He said he just thinks that this is part of the job today.

How do I remember that? We have a mnemonic, which is MAP. M is mirror, micro, media. A is answer: why, what, where. P is people, place, proof. My thinking on this is that as AI becomes your customer's personal shopper, trust is what is going to matter. Ryan's closing argument was that the days of companies controlling the funnel are over, and you either lean in or you get forgotten.

Written from the recording of this episode of Business Lunch.

Show notes

In this episode of Business Lunch, Roland Frasier and Ryan Deiss explain how the classic four stage buying journey has collapsed into one moment, and why trust is the lid that keeps prospects “popping” in your pot. They unpack three forms of trust, Identity, Competence, and Proximity, with sharp wins and public flops (Nike, Sephora, Peloton, DSW, Starbucks, Apple, United). You’ll get simple creative frameworks to turn short form content into instant, in channel conversions and a 14 day sprint to prove it on a small budget.

Highlights

  • “It’s not a funnel anymore, it’s a popcorn popper. Your audience are kernels heating at different speeds. Trust is the lid that keeps them popping for you.”
  • “Competence trust means the brand ‘gets me’, often better than I can describe myself.”
  • “Employees outperform celebrities for reach and credibility, because most buyers are employees.”
  • “Frictionless is forgettable. Add desirable friction that helps buyers name their pain and act.”
  • “If you can’t pivot your model, bolt trust into your media: mirror micro media, why what where, people place proof.”

Mentioned in This Episode

Three Trust Types (MAP mnemonic):

  • M, Identity trust: Mirror → Micro → Media
  • A, Competence trust: “Answer” with Why → What → Where
  • P, Proximity trust: People → Place → Proof

Competence wins & misses: Nike’s “Why do it?” repositioning; Sephora tutorials lifting AOV; Peloton’s 2019 holiday ad backlash.

Proximity plays: DSW AR try ons; Starbucks barista TikToks; Apple retail specialists; cautionary tale, United Airlines viral incidents.

Localization tactics: regional currency/sites, geo specific visuals (city skylines), and micro influencers by market.

KPI effects: higher AOV/retention/loyalty from competence; higher LTV from proximity; employee posts driving outsized reach.

Takeaways for Operators

  • Stop chasing linear funnels; engineer trust in channel so action can happen immediately.
  • Use Why → What → Where to collapse steps: name the pain, show the fix, drop the link.
  • Turn staff into a media network: People → Place → Proof with incentives and simple tracking.
  • Localize by currency, domains, visuals, accents, micro influencers, it quietly multiplies conversion.
  • Run a 14 day sprint: baseline CAC/AOV → recruit 3 customers + 3 insiders → record shorts → post/boost winners → re measure.
  • Remember MAP: Mirror Micro Media; Answer (Why What Where); People Place Proof. Build trust, and the journey collapses in your favor.

🎧 Whether you’re in B2B services or retail, this playbook turns everyday posts into high trust, one step conversions, without celebrity budgets.

CONNECT 

• Ask Roland a question HERE.

RESOURCES:

• 7 Steps to Scalable workbook

• Get my book, Zero Down, FREE

To learn more about Roland Frasier 👉  https://msha.ke/rolandfrasier/

Connect with me on social:

🎵 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rolandfrasier

 📸  Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rolandfrasier/

📱 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RolandFrasierPage/

💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rolandfrasier/ 

Subscribe to Roland Frasier 👉  https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkHnnFgdaTCg8KBd7W_LGSw?sub_confirmation=1

Mentioned in this episode:

Join Roland & Ryan at Get Scalable Live

If you’re a founder, CEO, or operator running a 7 or 8 figure business, Get Scalable Live was built for you.

This is not your typical business event. It’s 3 days of hands on strategy, real world frameworks, and next level networking with the smartest operators in the game.

🗓 November 18 to 20, 2025

📍 San Diego, CA

🎉 Hosted by Ryan Deiss, Roland Frasier, and Richard Lindner

🎧 As a Business Lunch listener, you get 25% off your ticket.

Use code LUNCH at checkout.

Get Scalable Live

Free tools that go with this one

Keep going

More on this

Off the Org Chart

A weekly read for owners who think past the day to day.

You are subscribing to Off the Org Chart, a weekly email from Roland sent through Beehiiv. Unsubscribe anytime with one click. See the Privacy Policy.